Full Count
A Furiously Updated Red Sox Blog
WEEI.com Blog Network
Francona: David Ortiz needs to face left-handed pitchers 01.31.11 at 8:58 pm ET
By Alex Speier

David Ortiz endured significant lefty-righty splits in 2010, but manager Terry Francona still plans to play him against southpaws. (AP)

Red Sox manager Terry Francona, prior to a Town Hall meeting between team executives and members of the public, said that even though David Ortiz has endured a significant dropoff in his offense in recent seasons against left-handed pitchers, he does not believe that he can simply sit the DH against southpaws.

Ortiz hit .222 with a .275 OBP, .324 slugging mark and two homers in 185 at-bats against lefties. He hit .297/.416/.643 with 30 homers in 333 at-bats against right-handed pitchers. From 2008-10, Ortiz is hitting .218/.291/.393 against lefties, and .274/.383/.549 against right-handed pitchers. Meanwhile, in Mike Cameron and Jed Lowrie, the Red Sox will have a pair of strong bench options against left-handed pitchers. But Francona does not envision pushing Ortiz into a platoon.

“For David to be successful — and I see his numbers against lefties, believe me, I do — you can’t just sit him because I don’t know if he’d have as much success against righties. I know we believe that,” said Francona. “I think there are times where it’ll do him good to maybe give him a break against somebody he struggles with. That wasn’t necessarily the case [last] April. He was struggling against everybody, and we were struggling to win.”

Francona further elaborated on the difficult balancing act he faced last April, when Ortiz struggled desperately out of the gate for the second straight year, while Mike Lowell languished on the bench.

“For whatever reason, the last two years have been horrendous starts. Thankfully, he’s pulled out of it. There’s no getting around it. Last April was awful. It was hard. You get through it, and we had to kind of fire our way through it at times, and thankfully we did. But it was hard,” said Francona. “I lost a lot of sleep over that. We always tell guys the night before if they’re playing. It’s something that we do, and I’m real comfortable with it. I remember one night in New York, I think [CC] Sabathia might’ve been pitching (the next day), and for one of the few times since I’ve been here, I had to go out and tell guys, ‘I don’t know. We’ll call you tomorrow.’ Maybe in some places that’s normal, but it really bothered me. It was a lot of anxiety for an April game. It was important to them, so it should’ve been important to me.”

For complete Red Sox coverage, visit weei.com/redsox.

Read More: David Ortiz, Terry Francona, Print  |  Email  |  Bark It Up!  |  Digg It
  • elmer barney

    I believe David Ortiz will have a monster year because the media pressure will be on Gonzalez and Crawford. The Boston media hounds are going to want to know every detail about the newest additions to the team. That leaves David to concentrate on his individual tasks. He is a proud man and he loves playing baseball and he’s going to do well. Go Papi,go.

  • Robert

    Tito confirms what I have been saying all winter. Ortiz should sit down against lefties,but Tito won’t do it. What is the matter with this guy? (Tito)How can you offer the other team a nearly automatic out when you could send up a good RH bat? The stats are staring him right in the face! To say he won’t hit well against righties if he doesn’t face lefties is ridiculous.Troy Glaus is out there,a cheap platoon partner for Papi,who could fill in at 1st and 3rd. But, why should Theo aquire him if Tito won’t use him? It’s a shame to see your team’s chances sabotaged by the manager.

  • Mark

    Robert’s comment is typical of fans who look at players like robots and think a manager’s decisions can be made purely by numbers. Two facts: Ortiz is a human being. And Francona is really good at managing human beings.

    Here’s what I mean: You don’t just play Ortiz against righthanded pitchers and automatically get .300/.400/.550 for those at-bats. Instead, you would get an older player who gets rusty, who has even less likelihood of success against all pitchers. Part of the success of an everyday player is the confidence that comes from the rhythm of playing every day. You would also lose a little competitive edge by enabling opposing managers to know that you will not allow Ortiz to bat against lefties. Francona understands this balance and his comments reflect that.

    Platoons work for some players but rarely for stars who have always been everyday players. Judge Ortiz on the entire body of work — in 2010, .270/.370/.529 with 32 HR and 102 RBI. I’ll take that in a second, and do so knowing that Tito will sit him against the toughest lefties and pinch-hit for him once in a while when the matchups clearly dictate that.

    Francona knows how to manage people and get the most out of them. His patience with Ortiz last April and May, when most fans thought he was being blindly loyal to the detriment of the team, turned out to be dead-on correct.

  • http://www.lefthandedlife.com Matt

    Everyone goes through a slump. I say let Ortiz play, and he’ll figure it out and be back to being awesome!

  • Robert

    Mark,Ortiz plays 70 percent of the time. That should be enough AB’s to keep him from getting rusty.This is why Tito’s remark made no sense.The stats show that he hit .297 against righties and in the low 2′s against lefties.Looking at the big picture,his career with the Red Sox has been excellent,but his lefty stats don’t lie.A good team player would volunteer to sit down. He is getting older and the problem hurts the team and costs them victories.Ortiz knows this and doesn’t seem to care. It’s one thing to manage people and its another thing to pamper aging super stars.Ortiz does not make Tito’s job any easier tossing tantrums if asked to sit down.IMO,platoons should be used alot more in baseball.

  • Babe Ruth

    A slump? against left handed pitching this guy is one of the worst hitter’s in baseball period, i guess tito is willing to let him and Drew another bum make automatic outs batting against left handed pitching. 222 what a power house 2 homers this guy is a shell of himself

  • http://www.kipptyupp.com deedydoodoo

    So the end is near and so i bid….

  • http://stylewweathervane.multiply.com/journal/item/1/Weathervane_Top_Of_The_Line weathervane

    Hello! I’ve been reading your blog for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Atascocita Texas! Just wanted to say keep up the good job!

Red Sox Box Score
Red Sox Schedule
Baseball Analytics Blog
Red Sox Headlines
Red Sox Minor League News
Red Sox Team Leaders
MLB Headlines
Tips & Feedback

Verify