Full Count
A Furiously Updated Red Sox Blog
WEEI.com Blog Network
Five quick thoughts on the Red Sox trade for Andrew Bailey 12.28.11 at 5:52 pm ET
By Alex Speier

A major league source has confirmed that the Red Sox have traded outfielder Josh Reddick, first baseman Miles Head and right-hander Raul Alcantara to the A’s for closer Andrew Bailey and outfielder Ryan Sweeney. A few quick reactions to the trade:

1) The Red Sox have built a solid back-end of their bullpen, with further reinforcements such as Ryan Madson unlikely. Both Andrew Bailey and Mark Melancon, along with — in all likelihood — either Daniel Bard or Alfredo Aceves (one of whom is likely to end up in the rotation, the other in the bullpen) and Bobby Jenks (whom the Sox expect to have back) creates late-innings depth, particularly if Matt Albers and/or Felix Doubront and/or Franklin Morales can further lengthen the group.

The Sox have seen Bailey — a two-time All-Star — show the kind of stuff to be one of the elite closers in the American League. He’ll almost surely be the end-of-game option for the Sox as well. Though there have been health questions about him in recent seasons, the other pitchers with closing experience and/or potential (Melancon, Jenks, Bard/Aceves) permits the Sox to be insulated (at least on paper) should he be sidelined.

2) The Sox still have money to spend. They won’t be spending a ton, but in adding Melancon and Bailey through trades, the Sox acquired two solid late-innings arms who will cost less than a third of Jonathan Papelbon next season. As such, the team still has some money to either sign or trade for a starter. That will be their primary offseason need going forward.

3) In exchanging Reddick for Sweeney, the Sox parted with a major league outfielder with upside in Reddick in exchange for a player whose on-base skills and ability to play all three outfield positions will fit into the club’s short-term needs. Right now, Sweeney and Darnell McDonald wouild be the Sox’ right field combination, though the Sox are still looking at right-handed outfield bats. Regardless, the Sox were likely going to get to a point where they had to trade either Reddick or Ryan Kalish at some point given the potential positional redundancy of the two. In a best-case scenario for the Sox, Kalish would be ready to be an everyday big league outfielder by the middle of 2012. Reddick would have been that for them right now, but the upgrade to Bailey with the anticipated availability of Kalish in the not-too-distant future made this deal feasible.

Sweeney, a former second-round pick, is a career .283/.342/.378/.720 hitter. The Sox believe that his swing and approach will both play well at Fenway Park.

4) Alcantara was the clear second component of the deal. When the Sox were scared away from the Rich Harden trade this summer, it was because they couldn’t stomach the prospect of losing Alcantara as the second piece in the deal.

It’s almost impossible to say what the 19-year-old will be. He’s a relatively raw right-hander with a big arm. He dominated in the Gulf Coast League (0.75 ERA in 48 innings) and faced adversity after a mid-year promotion to Lowell (6.23 ERA in 17 1/3 innings). His fastball/breaking ball combination suggest at least long-term big league bullpen potential, and he has the upside of a starter. Still, he’s likely at least five years from a regular job in the majors, and there’s immense uncertainty about his future. That being the case, he’s precisely the type of player for whom the A’s (whose visions of contention are entirely driven by the long term) should deal, and the type of player for whom the Sox cannot sabotage a deal.

5) Head made a significant jump in his prospect status this year by producing a dominant stretch with Single-A Greenville and then holding his own as a younger player in the Carolina League with High-A Salem. He doesn’t wow anyone with his physique or athleticism (he would be an atypical success story, having to follow a path of someone like a Billy Butler), but the 26th rounder (who signed for $335,000 in 2009) has always left the Sox convinced he can hit.

The first baseman garnered little attention in the Sox’ system while hitting .240/.328/.341/.669 with one homer in Short-Season Lowell in 2010. But in Greenville this year, Head asserted himself in a way that ensured he could no longer be overlooked.

The 20-year-old earned a promotion to Hi-A Salem in late-June after leading the South Atlantic League in average (.338), slugging (.612), OPS (1.022) and extra-base hits (41 in 66 games). His consistent results reflect both improved conditioning as well as an improved mental approach to the game.

“Last year, I was getting myself out chasing pitches or swinging at maybe not a hitter’s pitch in a hitter’s count,” said Head. “This year, I’ve figured out my approach and stuck with it.”

Still, Head was never going to leapfrog Adrian Gonzalez as the first baseman of the future, so he represented a moveable piece. He hit .254/.328/.405/.733 with seven homers in 63 games with the Salem Sox.

Read More: Andrew Bailey, Hot Stove 2011, josh reddick, miles head Print  |  Email  |  Bark It Up!  |  Digg It
  • Anonymous

    Wow, Reddick got so hot in 2011, he carried the Sox through July as a rook.  Thought he’d be untouchable, will really miss him.  OK, so we boosted up the bullpen, but we’re deficient for 1 starter and some bats in the outfield, and we’ve given away some pieces.  Hope it’s not a rebuilding year, I feel the time for Beckett, Ortiz, Youk is now.

  • RedSoxFanInNJ

    Reddick did a great job and exceeded expectations I think. RF seems a little lite now…

  • GoSox!

    Great Move. I thought Reddick’s trade value was the highest at the deadline. Kalish will be ready at some point this year and is younger than Reddick. Need bullpen depth we can cantrol for years and free up payroll for a starter.

  • Anonymous

    2 starters. assuming bard will end up in the rotation seems like a stretch. he hasn’t started in years..and when he did, he was horrible. im afraid it will end like joba the hutt in ny..he was dominant in the pen..but a batting practice starter…and  speaking of job..i wonder how the yankees front office took it when they heard about joba’s dui..and how he tried getting out of it by telling the cop that he played for the yankees.

  • jrfrom508

    his dui in 09? not defending yankees or anything but really bro? maybe time to let it go

  • http://profiles.yahoo.com/u/ZVFM2HRNC5CTO2OUXD4XTX65O4 Dennis

     McDonald?  Please.  There should be someone in the scrap heap that would be better than McDonald. He was terrible last year.

  • Vtbashor

    Reddick had his month in the sun. Undisciplined hitter. Terrible outfielder. Quite expendable.

  • HoleinOne

    Would have rathered Sox saved ammo for a young starter.  With most starters having back or other medical issues, rotation in flux.  Counting on Bard a high risk.

  • Widegauge69

    Jacking up pitching deals by trading solid players for ones that are questionable was Theo’s strength… Meet the new boss same as the old boss

  • Rick in NH

    Reddick will probably be a serviceable 4th or 5th MLB outfielder. I think we saw him at his best in July. Once the combination of his being seen by the league and his lack of plate discipline made it clear that he wasn’t in the long-term plans. Sweeney seems to me to be the more valuable asset.

  • Nate

    First off, Lester is a #1 starter.  Second, Reddick is nowhere near untouchable (obviously).  Kalish is the OF prospect with a much higher ceiling than Reddick.  Third, you can’t have a rebuilding year when you have so many large contracts on your team – every season they should be a title contender.  They really haven’t lost anything this offseason, they’ve actually gotten better, I’ll swap Melancon and Bailey for Papelbon any day of the week.  Keep in mind, in 2012 Ellsbury is arbitration eligible.  His massive payday is right on the horizon and Boston is being smart by saving money now, so they can afford players like Ellsbury later.

  • teds red seat

    Completely agree Nate. Kalish was on track to be with the Sox ahead of Reddick, but the injury sidetracked him. As for Ellsbury, if he follows up this year with anything close to 2011, the cost will probably be north of 12M in arbitration, while a long term deal could approach Crawfords’. If Bailey stays healthy, a good deal.

  • Eddie Kasko

    Key is Bailey’s health…if he is healthy it’s a great deal.  Reddick was not the right field answer.  Sox do need to address situation…McDonald can’t be part of even a platoon equation.  With Cuddyer, Kubel, and Beltran out of the mix who is left?  I’d rather give Kalish a chance t ostart out of the gate. 

  • Anonymous

    Don’t worry to much about the loss of Reddick. He had a decent 6 weeks,and then the league figured him out.

Red Sox Box Score
Red Sox Schedule
Baseball Analytics Blog
Red Sox Headlines
Red Sox Minor League News
Red Sox Team Leaders
MLB Headlines
Tips & Feedback

Verify