| Is there a problem with Adrian Gonzalez? | 02.16.12 at 1:33 pm ET |

Adrian Gonzalez led the American League with 213 hits last season. (AP)
One year into his Red Sox career, is it fair to be critical of Adrian Gonzalez?
Well, not at first, second or third glance, no. A quick swing over to his baseball-reference page (tragically, the Baseball Encyclopedia takes a seat next to privacy, the music industry and any chance of making a profit in pornography as just three of about 50 million things wiped out by the Internet) and we see that in his first year in Boston, Gonzalez hit .338 with 27 homers and 117 RBI. He was third in the AL with a .957 OPS, led the league with 213 hits and very deservedly won his third career Gold Glove.
OK, maybe you expected a little more power — he was two years removed from a 40-homer season and escaped Petco Park — but any semi-reasonable fan would’ve signed for those numbers from Gonzalez in 2011, right?
Throw in the idea that he was transitioning from a city where absolutely no one cares about baseball (or anything else, really — I lived there for five years and can tell you that sunny and 68 degrees every day sucks the passion out of people, unless we’re talking about guacamole or any Kardashian) to a city where I think we can all agree people probably care too much and didn’t seem at all affected by the change is no small feat.
We see guys crumble all the time around here, I think it happened to the other high-priced addition to the 2011 Red Sox. Carl Crawford looked miscast and frankly uncomfortable from day one of spring training, but Gonzalez stepped in and looked like he had been around for a decade.
So realistically it’s hard to look at Gonzalez as a “problem.” This isn’t John Lackey or Dice-K or J.D. Drew. Just the opposite. In Year One (and he was only making $6 million in 2011) he was worth the dough. But something has happened with Gonzalez, there has been a serious shift in public perception.
And, to be fair, at least part of it was a second-half slump (again, Gonzalez sets a tough standard, but his slugging percentage was .489 in the second half, down 102 points from the first half) and part of it was his failures against the Yankees (.183/.298/.324) and the Rays (131/.293/.279). And, like everything else that followed after Game 162, all or at least much would have been forgiven if the Sox had figured out a way to win just one more game in September.
But they didn’t, of course, and instead they took a place on the very, very shortlist of greatest collapses in MLB history. Here’s the problem for Gonzalez — that list also includes the 2010 San Diego Padres.
Was Gonzalez anywhere close to the main reason the Padres and Sox missed the postseason? Nope. To suggest that it’s more than coincidence – as some have suggested — borders on ludicrous.
But here’s what rubs even level-headed folks the wrong way: Gonzalez has a demeanor (not unlike the aforementioned Drew) that suggests something south of obsession when it comes to winning. And he has a terrible habit of saying exactly what Sox fans don’t want to hear.
After 7-20 and Kyle Weiland and Erik Bedard and Lackey and the disaster in Baltimore no one wanted to listen to Gonzalez tell us that the Red Sox had just choked at the highest peak of choking because it was “God’s plan.” You might think it’s true — personally, I think God probably stopped watching baseball once games started averaging over three hours — but people want anger after what had just happened, or at least some acknowledgement of fault.
Look, I hate writing the words “chicken and beer” at this point. For me, it was overblown from the start — if Clay Buchholz had been healthy or Daniel Bard had been merely lousy instead of horrendous in September this stuff would been completely irrelevant — but we can all agree that it was evidence of a team that, to some degree, lost its way. And for Gonzalez to tell Hannah Storm (who is still a Type A Cougar Free Agent but is starting to slip) that “people have to eat, whether it’s chicken or steak” tells me that he just doesn’t get it. It simply reeks of arrogance and if he cares at all he has to know better.
And that’s not going to change. Gonzalez isn’t going to be Dustin Pedroia-Tedy Bruschi type. He’ll never be embraced. It’s just not his way. Admired, sure, but I don’t think he’ll ever be a “one of us” guy. And that’s OK, as long as he produces somewhere close to an MVP level.
I’ve heard (and read) people compare him to Wade Boggs in a negative way. He only cares about stats, me first, all that stuff. I have no clue if that’s true and neither do you. Listen, Boggs was a historically great offensive player. If the Red Sox had nine Wade Boggs’ in the lineup during the 80s they would have won multiple World Series. If Gonzalez is obsessed with a .330 average or .430 OBP or 130 RBI, good for him.
Gonzalez is going to make $21 million this season. No athlete in this city will be paid more in 2012. He doesn’t have to be a clubhouse leader, or a voice of reason. None of that matters. What the Red Sox need from him in 2012 is an MVP-level season. The hitter we saw over the first half of the year for 162 games. Think 40 homers, 130 RBI and an OPS around 1.000. That was the expectation when he was brought it and that’s why he has a $160 million contract.
He puts together that kind of season (and hits against the Yankees and Rays) and the Sox make the postseason he can be as aloof as any human being has ever been and no one will care.
If he doesn’t, what he says (or doesn’t say) will still matter to plenty of people. And the criticism, fair or not, will only build. And that’s life away from sunny and 68.
-
Frank
-
Jordan
-
Anonymous
-
http://twitter.com/runaway3124 Devan Curry
-
http://www.massholesports.com/ MassholeSports
-
anon
-
James
-
http://twitter.com/runaway3124 Devan Curry
-
Chairman12347
-
Tuffd
-
Hub
-
Josh
-
broke
-
Anonymous
-
Produce
-
Becky
-
Kirkwisheshewasbillsimmons
-
Tim
-
sportsguy
-
Chairman12347
-
Rickywvaughn
-
Anonymous
-
Doug
-
Cjmcgowan22
-
Guest
-
Mike66r
-
Fenian
-
Anonymous
-
aaron
-
Really?
-
Bruinman86
-
george scott
-
dlreed52
-
Jcool
-
Etswanson
-
Anonymous
-
Bielawski82
-
GoodWriter?
-
guest
-
EarlSweatshirt
-
Sduhigg
-
Joel Sosa76
-
Aladriano13
-
Aladriano13
-
Kelly
-
guest
-
Tom
-
George
-
SANfan
-
Cyekim
-
Anonymous
-
Anonymous
-
cheapcnjerseys
[find tickets]
[find tickets]
[find tickets]


- Scott Podsednik To Boston, Cody Ross To DL Not Determined Yet
- Kevin Youkilis Recalled, Playing First Base
- Ryan Sweeney And The 7-Day DL
- Roles Forming In Red Sox Bullpen
- Greenville Drive Update: Jose Vinicio, Blake Swihart, Keury De La Cruz
- Rosenthal: Scott Podsednik Called Up
- Red Sox Minor Lines 5/21: No Hit



- Sox purchase Podsednik's contract, activate Youkilis
- The Book: Anthony Ranaudo
- Cup of Coffee: Portland no-hit by New Hampshire
- Scouting Scratch: A weekend at Hadlock
- Cup of Coffee: Brentz's four hits not enough for Portland
- Lin called up, Gomez optioned
- Cup of Coffee: Pimentel and Couch pitch well in losses
- Cup of Coffee: Portland pitching combines for shutout
- Weekly Notes: May 18th
- Checking on repeat players























