Full Count
A Furiously Updated Red Sox Blog
WEEI.com Blog Network
Opinion: Sox fans right to boo Josh Beckett 08.01.12 at 11:09 am ET
By Kirk Minihane
Josh Beckett has a 4.54 ERA this season. (AP)

Josh Beckett has a 4.54 ERA this season. (AP)

This time, the fans got it right.

As a rule, you shouldn’t boo an injured player. You know that, I know that, and the (alleged) sellout crowd at Fenway Park knows that.

But this is different.

The fans weren’t really booing Josh Beckett for leaving Tuesday night’s game with back spasms. It was a terrific excuse at the perfect time. They were booing Josh Beckett for last September, booing Josh Beckett for coming back this season and never acknowledging that he was a significant player in the collapse and all that followed, booing Josh Beckett for being a mediocre pitcher this season, a season that has defined Beckett every bit as much as 2007, booing Josh Beckett for playing golf after missing a start with an injury, booing Josh Beckett for being out of shape last season and looking out of shape this season, booing Josh Beckett for “We get 18 off days a year,” booing Josh Beckett for making $15 million (though to be fair, I’m pretty sure he didn’t go into Theo Epstein‘s office with a gun and a $68 million contract) and booing Josh Beckett for still being in Boston after the trade deadline, which also gave them a chance to boo Ben Cherington and Larry Lucchino.

Beckett was the face (or chins) of the collapse last year, and he’s still the face of a team that — even with a four-game winning streak — is a whopping two games over .500 on Aug. 1. The underachiever on a hugely underachieving team. Maybe this team will keep winning and winning and prove all of us wrong. Who knows? But if it doesn’t, and Beckett continues his individual duel of lousy starts vs. DL stints, nothing will change.

And we’re told that Beckett doesn’t care what we think, that, to paraphrase the late and very great Gore Vidal, beneath Beckett’s cold exterior, once you break the ice, you find cold water. OK. He’s not going to apologize for who he is and why he does (or doesn’t do) what he does. Stubborn, prideful, all that. Got it. And I think, for the most part, Beckett has been given a free pass around here. His managers (with Bobby Valentine every bit as guilty as Terry Francona), pitching coaches, front office, fellow pitchers (and doesn’t it just seem so wrong to see John Lackey in the dugout every night?) and, yes, the media all have played a role in enabling Beckett. And the fans are done with it. That’s what you heard Tuesday night.

And spare me the idea that fans in Boston should know better than to boo an injured player. No kidding. But this is an outlier. If Felix Doubront or Clay Buchholz or Alfredo Aceves or any other pitcher on the roster — Jon Lester included — left the game with a back injury, no one would boo. And if Josh Beckett had blown out his knee or broke an ankle and was carried off the field, no one would have booed.

There are those who think he was faking an injury Tuesday night, which is ridiculous at best. Think about it: Why would Beckett fake an injury? What’s the motivation? If he was going to do that he would have said he hurt himself warming up and skipped the start entirely. He only looks worse by leaving the game, and he knows that.

But Beckett has earned distrust, has invited suspicion by his actions on the mound and in the clubhouse last season. It’s fair to wonder what exactly has changed. And he looks exactly the same to me as he did last September, puffy (and 20 or 30 extra pounds can lead to back injuries, maybe someone in the organization should’ve mentioned that to Beckett in the offseason), ineffective and unapologetic.

As a rule, you should never boo an injured player.

But Josh Beckett has done — or hasn’t done — enough to be the exception to the rule.

Read More: Bobby Valentine, Josh Beckett, Print  |  Email  |  Bark It Up!  |  Digg It
  • Doug

    With me Kirk you have cemented your reputation of a typical “Boston Hack” aka as a yellow press reporter, why don’t you just go to work for Rupert Murdoch, he loves those low life writers that are in the Super Mkt Scandal Sheets, that’s where you belong, I promise I’ll never read you again.

  • Richsjb

    I totally agree!

  • Anonymous

    Wrong.  It was a big mistake to boo an injured player.  It should never be done.  And by doing it, it’s adding to the idea that Boston is a bad destination for a player, something that could hurt the franchise for years.  Only a very short time ago, Boston was considered a great place for a player to be.  When Jason Bay left, he didn’t want to leave.  Victor Martinez loved his time here and wanted to stay.  Adrian Beltre loved his time here and wanted to stay.  The emphasis was on the tremendous support players got and the fact that there was a full house at Fenway every night.  Look how all that has changed.  By creating an environment where players don’t want to be – and that environment is created by the mess in the front office, by having the manager call out a player like Kevin Youkilis who busts his balls with every single pitch, by having fans boo injured players, and by having sites like these attract commenters that want to get rid of any player who enters a slump.  David Ortiz would have been gone years ago had the blog commenters and radio talk show callers had their way.  And Clay Buchholz would have been demoted to the minors earlier this year rather than being allowed to end his slump at the big league level.  The Sox would have zero chance to make the playoffs without Clay.

  • Dubedigsit

    Dude!! What is up with all the Minihaters? This guy cant print two words without a bash party. Beckett isn’t a fat, useless malcontent all the sudden? Have you watched this guy pitch the past two years? Hate on something inaccurate kids and get your friggen heads together. And Doug, “aka” stands for also known as, so you don’t have to follow it with the word as, you moron. Please watch a youtube video on how to write a sentence before making your comments public. This is why America is last in everything.

  • Nomar122977

    fans should boo themselves for paying money to watch these overpaid bums !

  • Chris Loye

    You are one complete moron for even posting this .This is why Boston is what it is ..people like you.
    Go find a hole and sliver out every once and awhile to see there is a world outside yourself.Azzhole.

  • Sadiehawkins3945

    I would have been booing, too, had I been there.

  • Dano50

    So I guess we won’t be seeing your intelligent comments here eh?  What a devastating loss to the readers.  Sad day indeed.  PLEASE reconsider Dougie.  You WILL be missed. I for one am shattered.  

  • Dano50

    Pay them and they will come.

  • Dano50

    Hey there’s a plan!  Sheer genius.

  • Dano50

    Yeah.  What HE said.   Whoever “he” is.

  • Nighttrain75

    This is a tough one. Hard to agree with the fans for booing an injured player and at the same time it’s hard to fault them. Beckett has zero currency and those boos were the culmination of a years worth of frustration. Not much to say about it, “it is what it is”

  • Walt in Maryland

    When you say “we’re told” Beckett doesn’t care, who’s “telling” us?

    The media.  They — and — particularly reporters like you, have done more to create this impression of Beckett the pariah than Beckett himself.

  • Uconnmike

    I couldn’t agree with Kirk any more on this one.  He’s just writing what we are all thinking.  Beckett is a bloated, overrated D-Bag who doesn’t give a crap about anyone but himself.  He does that ridiculous interview with Braford and whines that he’s not wanted, blah blah blah and then basically gives the fans the finger by leaving the game with a little back discomfort.  The fans should boo his a** off the field and they should boo the owners and gm off the field as well.  To not jettison his trouble making, poor example butt off the team just shows the ownership of this team is completely out touch with their fan base and refuses to recognize that Beckett’s stuff is in free fall and his attitude is getting worse by the day.  Do they really think things are going to be any better the next 2 years?  They can’t be that dumb or oblivious can they?

  • acrossalloceans

    Sorry Kirk but that is just low. I dont care how much someone has frustrated and upset you, you dont kick them when they are down. It just isnt right. Show some class.

  • acrossalloceans

     It just goes to show the true nature of the generic “fan”.

  • Highrollers

    Josh Beckett, 2 words, “You Suck”, nobody likes you except your buddies Larry, Ben and Robert Bradford. The team is better off, you in the disable list!!

  • Lender

    Troll

  • Highrollers

    “cry me a river” Is Chubby cheek pitcher getting his feelings hurt, by the fans booing him!! I make millions of dollars sitting around eating Fried chicken and drinking beer with my bed buddies Lackey and Lester. “Whahhhh” Take a z-pack(6-pack) so your back gets better Over-rated, Over-paid cry baby.

  • Derek

    I was under the impression Beckett had the best ERA of the Sox rotation last year. I hate Minihane’s writing because he seems to think he speaks for all of us with his outlandish opinions. I don’t see how he can keep putting all the blame on Beckett for last September and this year. No one would’ve booed Lester if he came out of a game with an injury? I would! Lester is a whiney cry baby. Lester wants to be treated like he’s Tom Glavine in his prime, when he pitches more like Steve Avery

  • Anonymous

    Amen, Kurt. Nobody can really agree with a nandy-pandy like DOUG can they? There is nothing in this article, Doug that is even close to inaccurate.

  • soxsuck

    Beckett is fat, out of shape, and useless. Glad we still think Beckett is the 2007 version. Oh that’s right I forgot we are taking the Duquette and Chiarelli mentality with Beckett leading the league with 10 quality starts. “More days in first place”,Only team to make it to the second round then anybody else”
    Kirk keep up the good work.

  • Kwgerds

    Fans have THE RIGHT to boo, but that does not mean it IS right!

  • Peter

    It is time to dump Beckett. I think he is the bad apple in the clubhouse.He is always hurt or playing golf. I also say give Bigpapi a 2 year contract. He is the only one giving 100 percent. He is carring this team. Let him end his career in a red sox uniform not a yankee one.
    The sox have one good run left in them.
    GO SOX

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NHACS2B2N4KZEBDMLTL4YUSHSE masinick

    Fans pay a lot of money to go to games.  Josh Beckett gets a lot of money to perform.  Fans don’t have a right to try to do anything physically damaging to anyone, but they do have every right to be vocal about their pleasure when someone satisfies their love of the game and their displeasure when they don’t.  Beckett has underperformed his worth for a considerable part of his contract and deserves all the criticism he gets.  He makes excuses when things don’t go right.  Perhaps some people are too hard on him, but he appears to bring it on.  If he had more of an attitude that people are paying a lot of money to see a good performance and feels an obligation to win and contribute, I suspect there would be a lot less venom coming his way.  Compare the Sox and the Patriots.  Fans seem more tolerant of Patriot failures because there is never doubt about the effort put out.  That cannot be said of what we see from Beckett.  Sometimes its there, often it is not evident.  He had a great start the other night, then “got a bad back”!  What’s up with that?  Work out properly and things like that are far less likely to occur.  Or is he too old already and washed up?  Too bad we’re stuck with his contract.  There have to be others who are more hungry to play the game.
     

  • Peter

    nicely put. you hit the nail right on the head.

  • Dachsies2mom

    Thanks Kirk for putting into words exactly how I (and I think much of RS Nation) feel.  I appreciate what Beckett did in ’07 and he gave us a couple of good years, but he is an arrogant entitled jerk who isn’t delivering and working to his potential and that attitude deserves to be booed anytime.

  • Rmg333

    Well said

  • Patti

    I couldn’t have said it better!

Red Sox Box Score
Red Sox Schedule
Baseball Analytics Blog
Red Sox Headlines
Red Sox Minor League News
Red Sox Team Leaders
MLB Headlines
Tips & Feedback

Verify