Full Count
A Furiously Updated Red Sox Blog
WEEI.com Blog Network
A look at what the Red Sox will do without Will Middlebrooks 08.11.12 at 9:40 am ET
By Rob Bradford

Will Middlebrooks reacts after suffering a fractured right wrist Friday night. (AP)

According to a team source, Will Middlebrooks suffered a fractured right wrist after being hit by a 96 mph fastball from Esmil Rogers in the ninth inning of the Red Sox’ 3-2 win over the Indians Friday night.

So, where do the Red Sox go from here?

The team hasn’t ruled out Middlebrooks returning this season, but it would probably behoove the Red Sox to proceed as if living life without the rookie for the remainder of ’12 is the likely scenario.

Here are the team’s third base options:

Pedro Ciriaco: The latest “most popular athlete in Boston” hasn’t played any third base for the Red Sox since joining the team this season, although he does have experience at the position.

Ciriaco played two major league games at third with the Pirates in ’11, albeit for just six innings, after playing one game there for Triple-A Indianapolis. He also manned third base for three games this season with Triple-A Pawtucket.

Red Sox manager Bobby Valentine has clearly prioritized finding ways to get Ciriaco into the lineup, as has been evidenced by the 26-year-old manning four different positions (including designated hitter).

Ciriaco hasn’t hit a wall as of yet, still maintaining a .341 batting average, and .831 OPS, while going 6-for-6 in stolen base attempts. In his 28 appearances, only one time has he has only gone two straight starts in which he has failed to manage at least one hit.

Nick Punto: The veteran infielder has played more games at third base (22) than any other position this season. He also manned third 48 times in ’10.

The 34-year-old has struggled offensively this season – hitting .200 with a .302 on-base percentage – and the average goes down to .159 when looking at games solely played at third.

But Punto  may represent the team’s best defensive option at third base, and he has hit better when getting consistent playing time, as was exemplified during a six-game stretch filling in for Dustin Pedroia from May 29-June 3.

Danny Valencia: The newly-acquired third baseman – who is being added to the 25-man roster — has never played any other position but the hot corner and was the Twins’ everyday player at the position through the ’11 season.

During that run as Minnesota’s regular third baseman, Valencia hit .246 with an OPS of .677 and 15 homers in 154 games. He got off to a bad start, hitting .219 in the season’s first three months, but rebounded to show some promise via a .294 average and .783 OPS in July and August.

Valencia wasn’t able to carry over the momentum this season, hitting just .198 with an OPS of .522 before being dealt to the Red Sox.

Valencia had played in just two games with the Pawtucket Red Sox, coming away with two hits and a pair of walks in nine plate appearances.

Mike Aviles: The Red Sox could choose to move Aviles over to third base and play Ciriaco consistently at shortstop, although there has been some hesitation to move the infielder out of short at any time this season. Aviles has 60 games of major league experience at third, including 22 appearances with the Red Sox in ’11.

And, in case you were wondering about the value of Middlebrooks, understand that the Red Sox are 43-32 in games he has played in. He is third on the team in OPS (.835), while managing a .333 average with runners on base, and .332 clip with runners in scoring position.

Middlebrooks is also hitting .306 with a .923 OPS from after the sixth inning.

And no Middlebrooks’ post would be complete this season without the inevitable Kevin Youkilis update …

Since the trade with the White Sox, Youkilis is hitting .244 with an .846 OPS and nine home runs, with Chicago totaling a 23-14 record in games he has played. During that span, Middlebrooks  – who had been sidelined with hamstring issues even before this trip to the disabled list – has hit .244 with a .700 OPS and six homers during the span.

It should be noted, however, that since July 23 Middlebrooks has out-performed Youkilis, hitting .300 with an .887 OPS. Over that span, the Chicago third baseman is hitting just .184 with an OPS of .814.

Print  |  Email  |  Bark It Up!  |  Digg It
  • Devils Advocate

    It’s a bad break for Middlebrooks, but with so many Red Sox players going down with potential season ending (and even career altering) injuries IT IS NOT A COINCIDENCE. And I’m not even talking the 2012 season, the Red Sox lost a lot of players in 2011 (including Ryan Kalish in the minors) and lead the league in DL days in 2010 as well.

    In the meantime, we hear about the chicken and beer scandal, which could account for very poor conditioning. We also hear about players trying to put off Tommy John surgery and “play through the pain” (Lackey, Crawford) or Dustin Pedroia trying to “tough it out” with a bad thumb that could get hurt a lot worse. We even hear about political power plays among the Red Sox medical staff, something that could lead to missed diagnosis and even ENCOURAGE “putting a band-aid on a bullet wound” and trying to send a hurt player back out there.

    When is John Henry going to realize that there is something very fundamentally flawed going on here? I say fire the whole medical staff, fire all the trainers, and start from scratch… before an outside investigation (by the media or otherwise) forces his hand.

  • realist

    Don’t forget iggy at ss and aviles at 3rd

  • Tuffd

    Bring Valencia up……….

  • Doug

    We just have to muddle on without Will he is going to be a great one and obviously we’ll miss him, but I think the way to go is Valencia, his numbers are Ok except for this year, he was alleged to have an attitude problem and that is basically why the Twins let him go with the rise of Plouffe at 3B.  I feel we’ve very little or no chance at the W.C. so why not play youngsters, play whomever until Sept, then get some kids up for Pawtucket & Portland etc, see what they have, use this opportunity to get some close looks at these potential stars or just wanna bes’.  The big focus over the Fall Winter & Spring obviously is pitching and more pitching, after you get more pitching, get more!  It’s the old refrain you never have enough pitching, oh, maybe quality ought to enter the picture Ben & Co.

  • Doug

    We have already replaced the medical staff, how many times do you suggest we do that?  Lackey pitched a long time with a shredded elbow and still managed to go over .500, I’m thinking he’ll be a darn good pitcher after rehab!  I know that goes against the popular throw him under the bus theory of the RSN Fault Finding Crew.  Even with the new medical staff, they almost killed Bobby Jenks, so you might say there still is a problem, or you could just forget it happened.

  • anguillaman3

    Well….there are some solutions…but none as good as the guy that is now injured (Middlebrooks)….geeze…still 6 weeks or so of this torture remains.

  • Doug

    I feel your pain, this is not the end of the world, I’ve been following the Red Sox since age 6 or 7 in 1950 & since then there have been worse season than this, much worse, but that doesn’t alter YOUR feelings, there are just so many things that have gone wrong, it’s going to be a long Winter, hopefully we can find out part of the problems on the medical staff and get some decent pitchers over the off season, hang in there.  It could be worse!

  • Sandy Peterson

    Bye bye Soxypoos… See you in 2013! Suuukkkas!!!

  • Bielawski82

    “Red Sox manager Bobby Valentine has clearly prioritized finding ways to get Ciriaco into the lineup, as has been evidenced by the 26-year-old manning four different positions (including designated hitter).”

    No kidding, the kid’s batting 340!  I don’t even see the point of this article, the only debate to be had is do you send Aviles to 3rd and let Ciriaco play 2nd or vice-versa.  There’s no excuse to ever let a 340 batting average sit on the bench.

  • Jaime29

    I would love to see them bring up Boegarts and Bradley. Heck the Orioles brought Machado up from AA and he’s doing just fine. 

  • Boris

    season’s over. let him heal. bring up prospects to look at.

Red Sox Box Score
Red Sox Schedule
Baseball Analytics Blog
Red Sox Headlines
Red Sox Minor League News
Red Sox Team Leaders
MLB Headlines
Tips & Feedback

Verify