Full Count
A Furiously Updated Red Sox Blog
WEEI.com Blog Network
Top 10 big-name Red Sox trades of last half-century 08.25.12 at 6:21 pm ET
By Morley Quatroche

Hanley Ramirez was part of a major Red Sox trade when he was sent to the Marlins as the key Sox chip in a deal for Josh Beckett and Mike Lowell after the 2005 season. Now, he awaits Beckett in Los Angeles as a member of the Dodgers. (AP)

With the Red Sox’ season quickly fading into oblivion and the fans growing disgruntled with the team, the organization had to make a move. Yet, what the team did caught almost everyone by surprise.

On Saturday the Red Sox traded Adrian Gonzalez, Carl Crawford, Josh Beckett and Nick Punto to the Dodgers for first basemen James Loney and some prospects. This trade will go down as one of the biggest August trades in MLB history and one of the biggest trades in Red Sox history.

In Loney, the Red Sox acquire a career .284 hitter who has struggled somewhat this season,  batting .254 with four homers and 33 RBIs. But more importantly the Sox dump most of the $261 million that’s owed to Beckett, Crawford and Gonzalez through 2018.

With that in mind, let’s examine the 10 biggest trades in the last 50 years of Red Sox history. These are trades involving at least one high-profile player (thus something like Jeff Bagwell for Larry Anderson doesn’t make the cut, as Bagwell was an unheralded minor leaguer at the time of the deal).

10. Dec. 6, 1976 — Cecil Cooper to Brewers for George Scott and Bernie Carbo

Cooper, at the time, was a young bat with great potential, but the Sox wanted to reacquire the veteran bats of Carbo (traded to Milwaukee just six months earlier) and Scott to add to their potent lineup. They let go of a future five-time All-Star in Cooper, while Carbo and Scott had solid seasons in 1977 but offered little after that.

9. Dec. 7, 1978 — Bill Lee to Expos for Stan Papi

Red Sox management tired of Lee, the odd but productive left-hander who clashed with manager Don Zimmer, and shipped him north of the border. In return they received Papi, who batted an abysmal .188 in 50 games for the Sox in 1979 and was sent to the Phillies in 1980 for catcher Dave Rader. Lee went on to have a solid season in 1979 with Montreal, going 16-10 with a 3.04 ERA, but didn’t do much after that.

8. July 31, 1997 — Heathcliff Slocumb to Mariners for Jason Varitek and Derek Lowe

Looking back on this trade, it’s highway robbery. The Sox sent average closer Slocumb to the Mariners for two guys who became fan favorites soon after. Varitek would man the Boston backstop for almost 15 full years, while Lowe became a standout starter and reliever — including in the 2002 season, when he went 21-7 and finished third in AL Cy Young voting. Both players were a part of the curse-breaking 2004 team, while Slocumb never saved more than 27 games after leaving Boston.

7. Nov. 28, 2003 — Casey Fossum, Brandon Lyon, Jorge De La Rosa and Michael Goss to Diamondbacks for Curt Schilling

Schilling was acquired for two average major league pitchers in Fossum and Lyon along with two minor leaguers, which could also be called robbery since Schilling was already a five-time All-Star and would finish second in Cy Young voting in his first season in Boston after going 21-6. He would also help Boston win two World Series, and his performance in the famous “bloody sock” game in Game 6 of the 2004 ALCS helped the Red Sox come back from a 3-0 series deficit to the Yankees.

6. Nov. 24, 2005 — Hanley Ramirez, Anibal Sanchez, Jesus Delgado and Harvey Garcia to Marlins for Josh Beckett, Mike Lowell and Guillermo Mota

Boston may have still been bathing in the glory of its first title in 86 years when it made this trade, but it certainly helped the team pick up its next title in 2007. Beckett and Lowell became staples on the Red Sox roster and both had monster years during the ’07 title run. Beckett was 20-7 with a 3.27 ERA while Lowell batted .324 with 21 homers and 120 RBIs. Ramirez went on to become a three-time All-Star, albeit one with some behavioral issues. Ironically, Beckett will be joining Ramirez in Los Angeles after the shortstop was sent there from Miami earlier this year.

5. May 25, 1984 — Dennis Eckersley and Mike Brumley to Cubs for Bill Buckner

Eckersley may be most known for his days closing games for the Athletics, but he was a solid starter for the Red Sox. In his first two seasons in Boston after being acquired from the Indians, he won 37 games combined and had an ERA of 2.99, but the next four years he would slowly decline as a starter and was eventually traded. Buckner is infamously known for his error that ended Game 6 of the 1986 World Serie, but he had some productive years in Boston, batting .279 for Boston over five years.

4. July 31, 2008 — Manny Ramirez to Dodgers in three-team trade that landed Jason Bay in Boston

Despite producing monster season after monster season in his eight-year career with Boston, Ramirez’ “Manny being Manny” persona become a tired act by 2008. The Red Sox capitalized on his solid first half of 2008 in order to acquire Bay from the Pirates in a three-team deal. Manny went on to hit .396 for the Dodgers that season, but Bay proved to be a great acquisition, hitting 36 homers and driving in 119 runs in 2009 while causing no distractions. Boston then avoided disaster by declining to re-sign Bay, who has struggled for the Mets, while Manny continued to make all the wrong choices, receiving two suspensions for violations of MLB’s policy on performance-enhancing drugs.

3. Jan. 23, 1981 — Fred Lynn and Steve Renko to Angels for Frank Tanana, Joe Rudi and Jim Dorsey

Lynn was a perennial All-Star outfielder for the Sox, including an AL MVP in 1975, and Renko was a journeyman pitcher who had a mediocre 1980. The Sox were trying to acquire pieces for Lynn so they could avoid losing him as a free agent. However, Rudi and Tanana each only lasted a single unsuccessful year in Boston, and Dorsey never could consistently crack the Red Sox rotation and only pitched in four games for Boston. Meanwhile, Lynn went on to be an All-Star for the Angels from 1981 to 1983.

2. July 31, 2004 — Nomar Garciaparra to Cubs in four-team deal that landed Doug Mientkiewicz from Twins and Orlando Cabrera from Expos

Garciaparra, who had been an immense fan favorite but had started to wear out his welcome by the middle of 2004, was traded in a deadline deal only four months before Boston would end its 86-year title drought. Cabrera ended up as a solid rental player, batting .294 in the second half of 2004, while Mientkiewicz served as a great defensive first baseman. Garciaparra continued his solid form with the Cubs before signing with the Dodgers in 2006 and making his final All-Star appearance in 2007.

1. Nov. 18, 1997 — Carl Pavano and Tony Armas Jr. to Expos for Pedro Martinez

Boston acquired the reigning NL Cy Young winner for minor league pitchers in Pavano and Armas Jr., which could rank as the best deal the Red Sox ever made. While Pavano had one All-Star season in 2004, Martinez gave the Red Sox an amazing seven years that included the a 2004 World Series title. Pedro won back-to-back Cy Youngs in 1999 and 2000, finishing his Red Sox career with an absurd 117-37 record and a dominant 2.52 ERA. It’s hard to decide which season was better, his 1999 campaign when he went 23-4 with a 2.07 ERA, or his 2000 season when he went 18-6 with a 1.74 ERA.

Read More: adrian gonzalez, Curt Schilling, Dennis Eckersley, Fred Lynn Print  |  Email  |  Bark It Up!  |  Digg It
  • Anonymous

    I’m partial to the July 1996 trade of lefthander Jamie Moyer to Seattle for thirdbaseman Darren Bragg. Moyer went on to win 203 more games, including 145 for the Mariners. Bragg posted a .264/.346/.395/.741 line in 340 games over three seasons with the Red Sox.

  • Ribeyepike

    Don’t forget the heist of Dennis Eckersley from the Indians with Fred Kendall for Rick Wise, Mike Paxton, Ted Cox and Bo Diaz.  Eck went on to win 20 in his first year with the Sox

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/2LXXYHGWXLXFDGUXADGEZAYFDQ Sean

    he was an outfielder harmony….

  • Anonymous

    Thanks, Sean … I made the correction.

  • JiminNC

    You’re leaving out the several trades in which the ox sent away Reggie Smith, Tony C, Billy C, Jim Lomborg and George Scott

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/MVP7Q6J7MUXZ55PYW5OI3SUTJQ Jason Salvatore

    Looking at the numbers Shilling, Lowe, and Pedro put up in their best years really makes me realize how bad our pitching has been. Don’t get me wrong I wouldn’t care if our best pitcher only won 10 games in a WS wiining year and we had to use a ton of pitchers but it would be so nice to have a true ace and it doesn’t seem like we will ever have one again.

  • http://www.facebook.com/brent.lafond Brent Lafond

     Feels like that I no but reality is we will have aces again lets just hope atleast one of those aces is playing for us soon

  • Bielawski82

    I’m probably of the minority among Sox fans when I say we won the 2004 title despite, rather than because of trading Nomar.  Defense over offense just doesn’t add up if you ask me…

  • Robert

    Cecil Cooper. This  one really hurt. If the Sox had won the’77 pennant with aid from Carbo and Scott’s last good year, it might not be so bad. The Sox should have had a 3-4-5 trio with Lynn 3rd,Rice 4th,and Cooper 5th for many years.

    Lynn:  Trading Lynn was a cheap and stupid move by then GM, Haywood Sullivan,who also let Carlton Fisk walk for nothing. How do you trade Freddy Lynn, who was born to hit in Fenway?Think: Lynn,Rice, Cooper,Fisk, and Dewey Evans,from 78, and on.

    Another back breaker was Reggie Smith who became a star in the NL. Smith shoud have remained in RF until 1980,when Evans finnaly put it together. He would have made the difference in 74,76,77,and 78.

    Ben Oglivie for Dick McAuliffe. Had they kept Benji, they would have had a guy who finished with
    235 HR’s,941 RBI, and a .273 AVE with 1615 hits.  In 1980, he hit 42 HR’s,116 RBI, with a .302 AVE and .362 OBP.  Yaz would have had to go earlier to fit in these guys.Yaz’s last really good season came in 1977.

    Sparky Lyle: This trade alone cost the Sox the 72-74-76-77 and 78 division titles,by itself..Just look it up. In each of those years, he would have put the Sox in to the post season. In ’75, he may have put the Sox past the Reds. Think 10th inning, game 7. Who would you rather have, to face the Red Machine, Lyle, or Jim Burton?

  • Robert

    As Jim mentioned in another post, Jim Lonborg. He was about to become an ace,again when traded to the Brewers in the fall of ’71. This was another devastating trade by the Sox. The gave up Scott, just as he was coming into his prime, along with Lonborg and Ken Brett.. In return, they got one good season from Marty Pattin (72), and a couple of so so seasons from Tommy Harper. Ken Brett put it together in ’72 with the Brewers,and had several more good seasons. 
     
    This trade only came about as a result of the awful Lyle deal. Needing a 1st baseman,without Scott, they traded Lyle for Danny Cater. Cater, a former Sox killer, did nothing and retired in 74.
     
    if they kept the best of the ’67 team, and merged it with the’75 team, there could have been a dynasty in the ’70′s

  • Robert

              The Pedro deal  really shouldn’t  count. Yes, Dan Duqutte did a nice job in using his Montreal connections, but, this was about a nearly bankrupt team being unable to pay it’s ace .Nowadays, there are few legitimate trades, like there use to be before free agency and huge salaries became a factor..before that, trades were about one GM out smarting the other.

    The Schilling deal was also about a team, (Arizona) dumping salaries. Credit goes to Theo for being aggresive and having the right prospects to make the deal.

    Speaking of Schilling, how about Brady Anderson and Curt Shilling for Mike Boddiker?

  • Anonymous

    How could leave out the Sparky Lyle deal?

  • Innovator

    Very nice call…
    How about Don Aase for Jerry Remy that same offseason!??!

  • Innovator

    Lynn’s wife wanted to move back to california,if you remember..He was gone anyway…Freddie says its his biggest regret….

  • Relax

    I think they missed one of the worst trades the Sox ever made.  A very productive pitcher in Aaron Sele to the Rangers for Jim Leyritz and Damon Buford.  I believe Bill Haselman also went to the Rangers in that trade but I could be wrong.

  • Domthedon

    Don’t Forget the Great “Sparky Lyle” trade to the “Yankees” for , mmmmmmm I can,t remember lol
    Now that was “Robbery without a Gun”

  • TedSox

    What I like is a trade article without a single mention of Jeff Bagwell. He has not even been mentioned in the comments.

  • Sarge

    Pedro was by far the most exciting Red Sox Player in my lifetime (I am 62), whether on the mound or the dugout.

  • BoBo Brazil

    You nailed this one. Bumbling Haywood Sulllivan completely unraveled the late ’70′s Red Sox with stupid moves, especially this trade that brought back two former players. I always imagined how the Sox would have done if they had the core of players listed in your post. Years later I had the personal pleasure of telling Mr. Sulivan what a schmuck he was for letting these players out of town. He was the worst GM of all time. 

  • My10sense

    Actually, Bagwell wasn’t all that unheralded–the Globe had a story about him a week or two before the trade–how he could be the best 3rd baseman in the system.  

    If somebody else hasn’t mentioned it, Lyle went for Danny Cater.  

    Fifty years albeit just barely) brings up a couple of other big name deals: former rookie of the year Don Schwall and battery mate Jim Pagliaroni for Dr. Strangeglove and Jack Lamabe and Earl Wilson for Don Demeter

  • Stumpsr

     Yes he is, article states that it he’s not counting it as Bagwell was a minor leaguer at the time.

  • Stumpsr

    The Lyle for Cater in addition to Bagwell was the worst for me. Another one not mentioned was Ken Harrelson, Juan Pizarro and Dick Ellsworthy to the Indians for Sonny Siebert, Joe Azcue and Vicente Romo. Siebert was a pretty decent pitcher while he was here while I think Harrelson retired to play golf (aka introducing the batting glove to the majors) professionally.
     

  • Typical Boston Fan

    really?? we are never going to have an ace again? meaning till the end of times the red sox will never again ever have an ace in their staff? please read your crap before you post

Red Sox Box Score
Red Sox Schedule
Baseball Analytics Blog
Red Sox Headlines
Red Sox Minor League News
Red Sox Team Leaders
MLB Headlines
Tips & Feedback

Verify